Podcast

Susan Averett, Lafayette College - The Surprising Impact of Child Care Tax Credits

On Lafayette College Week: Child care tax credits have a surprising impact.

Susan Averett, Charles A. Dana professor of economics, explores why.


Faculty Bio:

Susan Averett is the Charles A. Dana Professor of Economics at Lafayette College, where she has taught courses on women and the economy for over 20 years. Her research in applied microeconomics explores how public policies and social circumstances shape health and economic well-being. Susan is also a Research Fellow at the Institute of Labor Economics (IZA) and the Global Labor Organization (GLO), and she serves as Co-Editor of Economics & Human Biology.


Transcript:

Efforts to address the declining birth rates suggest making child-care more affordable, but our research suggests it’s not that simple.

Current child-care tax credits help working families offset some of their child-care expenses. In theory, lowering the cost of care could encourage families to have more children or increase investments in birth outcomes.

To test those ideas, we examined decades of data, tracking state child-care tax credits from their introduction in Vermont, Oregon, and Oklahoma in 1976 through 2019, when 24 states and the District of Columbia adopted some form of the policy.

The results were surprising.

Despite reducing child-care costs, tax credits had no measurable effect on fertility rates. Families were no more likely to have a child in states with more generous credits, and birth outcomes remained largely unchanged.

One reason why is scale. Child-care can cost thousands of dollars per year, while the average tax credit was only about five to six hundred dollars. That financial assistance helps manage expenses but is unlikely to influence the complex decision-making process of having a child.

Timing matters, too. Tax credits are often received months after paying for care, functioning more as relief than as an incentive for family-planning decisions.

What did change was mothers’ employment. State tax credits significantly increased labor force participation among married mothers.

Taken together, these findings suggest that the economics of having children turn out to be more complicated than the economics of paying for childcare.

Additionally, our research underscores the importance of considering labor market dynamics when evaluating the effectiveness of tax policies designed to impact the quantity or quality of births, as such policies have more pronounced effects on labor supply than on births.