Membership Programs Meetings Publications Advocacy Press Room About AAC&U
Association of American Colleges and Universities
Search Web Site
AAC&U
Resources on:
Liberal Education
General Education
Curriculum
Faculty
Institutional Change
Assessment
Diversity
Civic Engagement
Science & Health
Women
Global Learning

THE PREPARING FUTURE FACULTY PROGRAM: WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE?
by A. Leigh DeNeef

Table D: PFF "Value" Question Results: Sorted by Category
Category means are in bold. Means calculated in red represent the total means minus those activities 40% or more alumni reported "not covered" in their cluster.

Q#
Question
#Resp
Mean
Std Dev
% Not Cov

Professional development programs outside of PFF

19
T.A. Orientation or training
129
3.3
1.68
18.6
20
Pedagogical coursework
129
3.2
1.62
15.5
21
Career mentoring or development
128
3.1
1.78
43.8
22
Seminars on faculty roles/responsibilities
128
2.9
1.81
40.6
Means of Category
3.1(3.3)
29.6(17.1)

Overall: Job Search

29
C.V.
125
3.5
1.84
28.0
30
Cover Letter
126
3.4
1.86
33.3
31
Portfolio
126
3.8
1.97
25.4
32
Research statement
125
3.0
1.71
43.2
33
Teaching statement
127
4.0
1.73
13.4
34
Interview process
126
3.5
1.79
23.8
35
Job presentations
127
3.2
1.79
30.7
36
Locating potential jobs
126
2.9
1.71
34.1
37
Negotiating job offers
126
3.0
1.74
47.6
Means of Category
3.4(3.5)
31.0(27.0)

Overall: Faculty Life

38
Salary/benefits
126
3.0
1.74
40.5
39
Balancing research/teaching/service
125
3.9
1.62
12.0
40
Negotiating first years on job
125
3.5
1.78
25.6
41
Tenure process/criteria
125
3.5
1.78
24.8
42
Research/professional funding prospects
123
2.7
1.57
46.3
43
Institutional governance/departmental politics
123
3.6
1.67
16.3
Means of Category
3.4(3.6)
27.6(19.7)

Overall: Teaching

44
Course/syllabus design
126
3.5
1.78
23.8
45
Use of technology in classroom
126
3.3
1.82
27.0
46
Handling difficult teaching situations
126
3.5
1.64
17.5
47
Teaching diverse student populations
125
3.7
1.67
15.2
48
Assignments and grading
126
3.3
1.79
23.8
49
Lecturing, leading discussions or labs
126
3.6
1.64
14.3
50
Mentoring and advising students
126
3.3
1.67
19.8
51
Assessing your teaching
126
3.8
1.77
19.0
Means of Category
3.5
20.1

Aspects of Mentor Relationship

57
Experience with mentor's classes
97
4.2
1.94
20.6
58
Shadowing mentor
96
3.7
1.99
27.1
59
Discussion of faculty roles/responsibilities
97
4.0
1.47
7.2
60
Discussion/collaboration on research project
97
3.3
1.87
50.5
Means of Category
3.8(4.0)
26.4(18.3)

Site Visits: Activities

70
Observing classes
97
3.9
2.12
40.2
71
Discussion with faculty
96
4.2
1.11
2.1
72
Discussion with students
97
3.5
1.93
29.9
73
Observing faculty meetings
97
3.7
2.07
53.6
74
Visiting campus resources (labs, library, etc.)
96
3.4
1.72
18.8
Means of Category
3.7(3.7)
28.9(16.9)

Site Visits: Learned

75
Faculty life at cluster institutions
96
3.9
1.40
5.2
76
Student life/instruction at cluster institutions
96
3.4
1.46
10.4
77
Hiring criteria at cluster institutions
96
3.6
1.71
18.8
Means of Category
3.6
11.5

Program at Own Institution

78
Informal discussion groups
129
4.0
1.54
10.9
79
Informal programs or symposia
129
3.9
1.60
12.4
80
Pedagogy coursework
128
3.4
1.91
40.6
81
Practical workshops
128
3.8
1.89
23.4
Means of Category
3.8(3.9)
21.8(15.6)

Overall Impact of PFF

84
Overall: Career choices
128
3.9
1.62
9.4
85
Overall: Negotiating the job market
127
3.3
1.73
15.7
86
Overall: Negotiating the first years on the job
127
3.4
1.82
17.3
Means of Category
3.5
14.1

Other PFF Occasional Papers

IN THIS PUBLICATION

About This Publication
I. Introduction
II. General Findings from the Survey
III Alumni Narratives: A. Differences PFF made on the research campus
III Alumni Narratives: B. Differences PFF Made in Negotiating the Job Market
III Alumni Narratives: C. Differences PFF Made in the Initial Years in the Academy
IV. Conclusion
Appendix
Table A: PFF “Value” Question Results: Sorted by Mean
Table B: PFF “Value” Question Results: Sorted by Mean (w/out Duke)
Table C: PFF “Value” Question Results: Sorted by Category
Table D: PFF “Value” Question Results: Sorted by Category
Table E: PFF “Value” Question Results: Sorted by % Not Covered
Table F: PFF “Value” Question Mean Results: Sorted by Ethnicity
Table G: PFF “Value” Question Mean Results: Sorted by Discipline

Download PDF (400k)