December, 2002
Measuring Intellectual Intangibles: Student Engagement Survey
Releases Third Year Results

AsThe Washington Post writer, Jay Mathews, recently described it, The National Survey for Student Engagement (NSSE) "rate[s] a college's intellectual intangibles." Unlike other rankings of colleges and universities that focus on such factors as average SAT scores or rate of alumni annual giving, NSSE seeks to provide information about students' involvement with their learning. NSSE released its 2002 annual report, "From Promise to Progress: How Colleges and Universities Are Using Student Engagement Results to Improve Collegiate Quality," last month. The survey gauges the level of student engagement at four-year colleges and universities in the following categories:

1) Academic challenge
2) Active and collaborative learning
3) Student-faculty interaction
4) Enriching educational experiences
5) Supportive campus environment.

The study is designed to examine experiences that have been proven to enhance learning. Research studies have demonstrated that elements of each of these five clusters of activities are linked to desired outcomes in college. NSSE will conduct a "sister survey" for community colleges in 2003.


FINDINGS

  • Sixty-three percent of first-year students and 47 percent of seniors report never to have worked with faculty members on activities other than coursework.
  • Fifty-seven percent of all students say diverse perspectives (of race, religion, gender, and political beliefs) are often discussed in class or considered in assignments.

  • In general, students who come from differing racial and ethnic backgrounds appeared to engage in effective educational practices at comparable levels.

  • International students generally prove more engaged in different aspects of the college experience than are American students, especially in the first year. International students seem to make the most effective use of what college has to offer: they interact more frequently with faculty, perceive the campus environment as more supportive, score higher on academic challenge, engage in more diversity related activities, and report greater gains in personal and social development, political competence, and general education.

  • Latinos and Whites are the groups who report being most satisfied with their college experience, while Asian Pacific Americans and African Americans report the greatest gains in "personal growth."

  • Seventy-one percent of first-year students and 58 percent of seniors never participated in community-based projects as part of a regular course.

  • Being a transfer student (as forty percent of all seniors surveyed are) is negatively correlated with scores on all benchmark categories except for academic achievement, where they rank on par with native students. These experiences hold true across factors such as type of institution, sex, age, and race. They share these challenges with non-traditional-age students and commuter students.

  • Women in their senior year report shying away from majoring in computer and information science (3 percent) and Engineering (2 percent) more so than men (10 percent and 13 percent respectively). Women tend to major more in health-related fields and education (8 percent and 13 percent respectively) than men do (3 percent and 5 percent respectively).

  • Campus experiences related to diversity have a high positive correlation to other effective educational practices.

  • Learning communities are favorably linked to many other educationally purposeful activities and desired outcomes.
  • DID YOU KNOW?

    • Seventy percent of all students reported their advising as "good" or "excellent."

    • Transfer students are more likely to rewrite papers and to be prepared for class.

    • Women in science, math, engineering, and technology degrees spend more time studying then their male counterparts.

    • Nationally, 29 percent of first-year students and 22 percent of seniors report participating in some type of learning community.

    • Students who have spent time with others of a different race or ethnicity report the following: more progress in personal and educational growth, more involvement in active and collaborative learning, and a higher level of satisfaction with their college experience.

    • Nineteen percent of first-year students and 24% of seniors report A grades.

    • White students have the highest grades, followed by Asian, Latino, Native American, and African-American students, in that order.

    • Two-thirds of seniors did community service or volunteered during college.

    • Student engagement is highly correlated with a high GPA.

    • African Americans report more active and collaborative learning activities; Asian Pacific Americans prove the least engaged in these sorts of activities.


    To view the NSSE report, www.indiana.edu/~nsse/.

    George Kuh, NSSE's project director will be a speaker at AAC&U's annual meeting, The Courage to Question: Liberal Education in the 21st Century. For more information about the meeting, visit www.aacu.org/meetings/annual.cfm.

    To view The Washington Post article, "Rating a College's Intellectual Intangibles," visit www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A39214-2002Nov25.html.

    To view a column about the 2001 NSSE survey, visit www.aacu.org/aacu_news/March02/facts_figures.htm.